Thirteen years. Let that sink in for a moment. When Grand Theft Auto V came out in 2013, I had more hair, fewer responsibilities, and a genuine belief that I'd one day "get round to" finishing the Strangers and Freaks missions. I did not. Since then we've had three console generations' worth of re-releases, a pandemic, a mega leak, two delays, and roughly four thousand YouTube videos analysing the reflections in Lucia's sunglasses.
And now, the night before launch, the review embargo has lifted and the internet has collectively fallen off its chair.
Grand Theft Auto VI is sitting on a 99 on Metacritic for the PS5 version, from somewhere north of 145 critic reviews at the time of writing, and not a single one of them is mixed or negative. That ties The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, which has sat alone at the summit since 1998 on the strength of 22 reviews. With more than six times as many critics chipping in, GTA 6 has done it the hard way. Metacritic's own all-time list currently shows it in first place, just above Ocarina, which means somewhere, a Hylian is quietly packing up his desk.
OpenCritic tells the same story, with a top critic average of 99 at the time of writing and essentially every critic recommending it. The lowest scores on OpenCritic are 9/10s, from the likes of TheSixthAxis and PlayStation LifeStyle. Over on Metacritic, the most grumpy reviewer so far is ScreenHub with an 80, which still counts as a glowing recommendation. For most games, that would be the high point of the review cycle.
So, is it the game of the year? Is it, whisper it, the best game ever made? Let's dig in.
A Wall of Tens
I've been reading reviews all day (my partner thinks I've been "working") and the sheer consistency is the thing that gets you. IGN, GameSpot, Game Informer, Push Square, Giant Bomb and Destructoid all went 10/10. The Guardian, Eurogamer, GamesRadar+, VGC, TechRadar and Windows Central all handed out five stars. Rockstar didn't so much land a review cycle as conduct a coronation.
IGN's Luke Reilly put more than 120 hours into it across three weeks and called it "the single most impressive video game I have ever played." That is not a man who has played a handful of games. This is the same chap who has been revisiting the entire series for IGN's GTA retrospectives, so he knows exactly what he's comparing it to.
Over at Eurogamer, Chris Tapsell gave it five stars and described it as "a game of opposites and awe," which is the sort of line I wish I'd written. GamesRadar+'s Josh West called it "the highest-fidelity sandbox of its generation," and Giant Bomb's Dan Ryckert simply declared it Rockstar's best game. Considering Rockstar's back catalogue includes Red Dead Redemption 2, that's a bold hill to plant a flag on.
Rockstar didn't so much land a review cycle as conduct a coronation.
Welcome to Leonida, Mind the Wildlife
The star of almost every review isn't Jason or Lucia. It's Leonida itself, Rockstar's not at all thinly veiled Florida, with modern Vice City at its heart and swamps, keys and highways sprawling outwards.

Sammy Barker at Push Square spent more than 150 hours on PS5 Pro and called it "the deepest, densest, most accomplished open world since Red Dead Redemption 2." The examples critics keep coming back to are tiny, and that's exactly the point. Push Square describes insects gathering around discarded food wrappers, and a cyclist telling him off for his driving at a petrol station. Game Informer's Matt Miller talks about stumbling into traffic accidents and noticing shady types watching him at a cash machine. Forbes' Paul Tassi noticed NPCs passing comment on his tank top, characters juggling a beer in one hand and a sandwich in the other, and car doors opening sideways when parked in a tight spot.
My favourite stat of the whole day, though, comes from Tassi. He reckons he heard his first repeated line of ambient dialogue somewhere around the 60 hour mark. Sixty hours! I've played games where the shopkeeper has said "stay a while and listen" four times before I've found the door.
The Washington Post's Gene Park praised the way NPCs respond to you and get on with their own agendas, so a quick trip to the shops can spiral into something completely unplanned. That's GTA's magic in a nutshell, really: the stories you never meant to have. And by all accounts, Leonida is absolutely stuffed with them.
The Police Have Read the Manual This Time
GTA's wanted system has historically been about as sophisticated as a toddler with a whistle. You commit a crime, stars appear, you hide behind a bin until they go away. Lovely.
Not anymore. The new Heat system works off information. TechRadar's Rob Dwiar explains that witnesses, security cameras, and the clothes you're wearing or the car you're driving all shape how the police come looking for you. Change your outfit, ditch the motor, and you might just slip away. Turn up to the job in a bright pink tracksuit and a stolen sports car and, well, you've only got yourself to blame.
It goes further than that, too. Push Square notes that your criminal profile affects how the police and the wider world react to you, and that you can incapacitate targets rather than kill them. Robberies can be scouted, disguised and planned, with a getaway vehicle picked in advance, so a job can end without the obligatory twenty minute car chase. Imagine that. A GTA game that rewards you for being a clever criminal rather than a walking natural disaster.
Bonnie and Clyde, but with a Gym Membership
Here's the bit I genuinely didn't expect: the thing critics are most emotional about is the love story.
Jason Duval and Lucia Caminos aren't three strangers thrown together for a heist like Michael, Franklin and Trevor. They're a couple, and the game wants you to look after that relationship. Push Square describes Jason decorating his beach house before Lucia arrives, and if you put the effort in, the bond strengthens. Ignore it, and she'll notice you couldn't be bothered. Which, frankly, is the most realistic thing to ever happen in a Grand Theft Auto game.

You can hit the gym together, grab drinks, kiss and cuddle on the penthouse balcony, and even rob a petrol station as a duo. Forbes points out that little hearts pop up on screen when you do a robbery together, which is either deeply romantic or deeply concerning depending on your view of armed robbery as a date night. Tassi went as far as saying he couldn't remember a better relationship in a video game. Hardcore Gamer reckons the pair are so inseparable the game basically won't let either of them cheat. Rockstar has been clear that keeping them romantically together is optional, but most critics seem to have found that a bit like being told cake is optional.
The Guardian's Keza MacDonald admitted she didn't expect the game to make her so emotional, and The Verge's Andrew Webster went as far as calling it the most mature GTA Rockstar has ever made. When the people who've reviewed every GTA game since the PS2 are getting a bit misty eyed, you know something's landed.
And there's a payoff. Your choices about whether to keep the pair close or let them drift feed into multiple endings, though Push Square felt some of those choices are more illusion than real consequence. Still, it's a huge step up from "press X to choose which of your friends to murder."
Never Run Out of Things to Do
If you're worried there won't be enough to keep you busy, don't be. Push Square puts the main story at around 60 hours, reckons the average player will hit about 80 with side content, and thinks a 100% completion could run past 300 hours. Three. Hundred. Hours. I'll see you all in 2029.
The side activities read like a holiday brochure for people who also commit crimes. Fishing, mini golf, hunting, gym sessions, sightseeing and nightclub dancing are all in there, alongside store robberies, bank jobs, street races and side stories. Forbes mentions helping a mate boost a rap duo's career and planning a heist with a bank robber you absolutely shouldn't trust. There are also gang dens, which Tassi calls the toughest content in the whole game, harder than the vast majority of story missions. Push Square even found a fully playable games console sitting in Jason's house. A game inside the game. I'll be on that within twenty minutes, obviously.
Then there's the life sim side. Characters need to eat, exercise and refuel. Cars are fragile, repairs cost money, and the realism has a learning curve. It's very much Rockstar bringing the Red Dead "drink your milk" philosophy to Vice City, which you'll either adore or find mildly exhausting.
It's Not All Sunshine and Flamingos
Now, I'm not going to pretend this is a perfect game, because even the people handing out tens aren't pretending that either.
The big one is performance. GTA 6 targets 30 frames per second on every console, PS5 Pro included, and there's no performance mode. Push Square called that objectively disappointing but a necessary compromise for the scale, and frame pacing is reportedly solid. If you've been spoilt by 60fps, though, it'll take some adjusting. PC Gamer's Christopher Livingston, very impressed overall, suggested it'll be even greater when it eventually lands on PC. Patience, PC folk. Again.
Pacing gets a few grumbles too. Push Square feels the story is padded in places and drags in the later stages, while Forbes describes a stretch where the main plot basically sends you off to amuse yourself for a while. Worthplaying notes the opening chapters spend a lot of time on everyday life before things really kick off.
Combat isn't universally loved either. The Verge found it clunky and the weapon wheel frustrating, Push Square flagged bullet sponge enemies, and The Guardian's MacDonald described missions occasionally failing for reasons that weren't always clear. Ars Technica's Kyle Orland felt some of the satire had gone a bit stale. IGN's Reilly found the motorbikes stiffer than before and couldn't replay finished missions. (The Verge, Ars Technica and IGN points are all summarised by The National.) So yes, Rockstar is still Rockstar. Some of those old habits survived the 13 years.
So, Game of the Year?
The Game Awards nominations dropped yesterday, a full two days before the game is even out, and GTA 6 leads the pack with eight nominations, including Game of the Year, Best Narrative, Best Game Direction and Best Performance for Manni L. Perez as Lucia. The ceremony is on December 10, and it's up against some serious competition, but with a record-tying Metascore and the strongest critical consensus anyone can remember, it would take a brave jury to look the other way.
And the Best Game Ever Made?
This is where I have to be careful, because "best ever" is a dangerous phrase to throw around on launch eve.
Here's the case for it. No game has ever arrived with this many reviews and this little disagreement. Ocarina's 99 was earned from 22 critics in a very different era; GTA 6 matched it with well over a hundred more, in an age where reviewers have played everything and are not easily impressed. It builds on GTA IV's 98, and on GTA V and Red Dead Redemption 2, both of which hit 97. Rockstar has taken the world simulation of Red Dead, the scale and satire of GTA, and wrapped them around the most human story the series has ever told. Critics aren't just praising the size of the thing; they're praising how much it cares, down to bugs on a burger wrapper.
The case against? The players haven't spoken yet. Metacritic doesn't open user scores until 36 hours after launch, the 30fps cap will divide people, and "best game ever" is ultimately the kind of title that's decided over years of replaying, not a single Wednesday of reviews. Ocarina earned its throne because people were still talking about it two decades later.
What I will say is this: I can't remember a launch like it. Not GTA V, not Red Dead 2, not Elden Ring. If even half of what these reviewers are describing holds up when millions of us pile into Leonida at midnight, then GTA 6 isn't just going to be the game of the year. It's going to be the game we measure everything else against for the next decade.

Now if you'll excuse me, I need to free up a frankly offensive amount of storage, explain to my family why I'll be "busy" this weekend, and finally decide whether I'm the kind of Jason who decorates the beach house. (I'm not. I'm going to forget, Lucia will be disappointed, and it'll be like real life all over again.)
My own review will follow once I've actually put some proper hours in. See you in Vice City.
The Good
A 99 Metascore with zero mixed or negative reviews, tying the all-time record
Leonida is, by near universal agreement, the most detailed open world ever made
NPCs with their own lives, and dialogue that rarely repeats
A genuinely affecting love story at the heart of a GTA game, of all things
A smarter Heat system that rewards planning over chaos
An almost silly amount to do, with 100% completion possibly beyond 300 hours
The Not So Good
Locked to 30fps on every console, with no performance mode
Story pacing sags in places, especially later on
Combat and the weapon wheel still have their critics
Some satire reportedly lands with a thud
Sources
Reviews
Scores and roundups
Everything else
Written by TokenGeek for VGDB






